Also, asking Claude about this:
Yes, it would still work. Your second guess is right.
Why Frank’s two statements don’t conflict
The Pegasus has never shared anything over the network by itself. It’s just a big disk. The Mac it’s plugged into does the sharing. For 16 years that was the Mac Mini, using AFP. Frank meant that nothing on the network can connect to the Pegasus directly. A Mac sharing a drive that’s plugged into it is ordinary file sharing, and macOS 27 supports it over SMB.
So if you plug the Pegasus into the macOS 27 MacBook and turn on File Sharing there (System Settings > General > Sharing), the other laptop can reach it over SMB, the same way it used to reach the Mini. Any Mac from 2013 on supports SMB, so that part is fine.
The catch is that the MacBook becomes your server. Whenever it’s closed, asleep or out of the house, nobody else can get to the files.
A correction to your forum post
The direct connection didn’t fail because of the same problem. It failed because the Promise driver wasn’t installed. Apple Silicon Macs don’t include it, which is the point Frank is making. Once the driver and the Thunderbolt 3 to Thunderbolt 2 adapter are in place, a newer Mac should see the Pegasus fine. Moving it to a newer Mac is still a real option.
Options, cheapest first
- Today: install the driver and connect the Pegasus to the MacBook. Even if this isn’t the permanent setup, it gives you direct access. Back up the financial files and anything else critical before you change anything else.
- Upgrade the Mac Mini from Yosemite to High Sierra. It’s free. Frank’s notes say High Sierra is as far as a 2011 Mini can go, and its SMB server is three years newer than Yosemite’s. It may fix the network problem while keeping your current setup with the Mini as the server. Two cautions: back up the Mini first, and check that the Promise utility and driver support High Sierra on that machine. This might not work, but it costs nothing to try.
- Downgrade the MacBook to macOS 26. This is still possible, but I’d make it the last resort. Once the MacBook is held at 26, it eventually stops getting security updates. That matters on the machine you use for financial files.
About custom fixes: I share your caution, but the nsmb.conf file in Frank’s notes is a standard Apple settings file and not a hack. Updates don’t usually remove it, and deleting it with one command undoes it completely.
My suggestion is to start with option 1 today. Once your important files are safe, you can try option 2 without pressure.
Derek: the bottom line for me is this statement: "The catch is that the MacBook becomes your server. Whenever it’s closed, asleep or out of the house, nobody else can get to the files."
So the connection to the laptop is only a stop-gap solution. Another fix, I suppose, would be to upgrade the Mac Mini to a more modern one and hope the connection would "just work" that way?
Claude:
Yes. A newer Mac Mini as the server is the real long-term fix. It wouldn’t be completely plug-and-play, but it’s close.
Why it should work
The Pegasus is fine. The weak link is Yosemite’s 12-year-old file sharing. A newer Mini running a current macOS would share the Pegasus over modern SMB, which is what macOS 27 expects. You’d keep the same setup you’ve had for 16 years: the Mini stays on, the Pegasus is attached, and both laptops connect over Wi-Fi.
Setup you’d still need to do
- A Thunderbolt 3 to Thunderbolt 2 adapter, as Frank mentioned.
- On an Apple Silicon Mini, Promise’s DEXT driver, installed and approved.
- File Sharing turned on, with the Pegasus folders and user accounts added.
Test it with the MacBook before you buy anything
You can prove the whole setup works without spending money on a Mini:
- Install the driver on the MacBook, plug in the Pegasus with the adapter, and confirm you can see your files.
- Turn on File Sharing on the MacBook and connect from the other laptop.
If both steps work, a newer Mini will work the same way, because the MacBook is standing in for the Mini. That also turns the stop-gap into a dress rehearsal. And if something fails, you’ll know before you’ve spent anything.
What to look for in a Mini
Any Apple Silicon Mini (M1 or later) will do, and a used or refurbished one keeps the cost down. You don’t need much power to serve files. Avoid older Intel Minis: they’ll stop getting macOS updates sooner, and you’d be back in this situation in a few years.
The free option comes first
Upgrading the current Mini from Yosemite to High Sierra costs nothing. It might be enough to get you through until a new Mini fits the budget. Back up the Mini first and check that Promise supports High Sierra before you upgrade.
So the plan in order: install the driver on the MacBook and copy your critical files off. Then try High Sierra on the old Mini. Buy a newer Mini only if High Sierra doesn’t fix it.