Hi Tom,
That's a bit of an unusual situation, but it is not impossible to resolve.
Here's one way to go about it.
CAUTION: Make sure you power the Pegasus off between swapping the hard drives, if you remove a hard drive when the Pegasus is powered on it will be marked dead. I think with the Pegasus 2 removing the TB cable should cause the Pegasus to power off. But verify that the Pegasus powers off before continuing.
Open a terminal and start the CLI with the 'promiseutil' command. I have a Pegasus32 attached, but the process is the same. Note you can leave the CLI running for the entire process, no need to restart it. When you're done the 'exit' command will exit the CLI.
promise@promises-Mac-mini-2 ~ % promiseutil
-------------------------------------------------------------
Promise Utility
Version: 4.06.0000.01 Build Date: Aug 4, 2021
-------------------------------------------------------------
List available RAID HBAs and Subsystems
===============================================================================
Type # Model Alias WWN Seq
===============================================================================
hba 1 * Pegasus32 R4 Pegasus32 R4-PTU 2000-0001-5562-b957 1
Totally 1 HBA(s) and 0 Subsystem(s)
-------------------------------------------------------------
The row with '*' sign refers the current working HBA/Subsystem path
To change the current HBA/Subsystem path, you may use the following command:
spath -a chgpath -t hba|subsys -p <path #>.
Type help or ? to display all the available commands
-------------------------------------------------------------
cliib> logdrv
===============================================================================
LdId Alias OpStatus Capacity Stripe RAID CachePolicy SYNCed
===============================================================================
0 OK 1TB 1MB RAID0 RAhead/WBack Yes
cliib>
Use the 'logdrv' command to determine if the drive is part of a RAID0 or RAID5 set.
The 'logdrv' command shows that this drive is part of a RAID0 logical drive. Power the Pegasus down, remove the drive and mark mark it as RAID0 then insert a different drive and power up the Pegasus and determine if it's from a RAID0 or RAID5 set.
You only need to do this till you find (4) disks of the same RAID type, the others disks are from the other RAID set.
Install the sets in each Pegasus2, attach them to your MAC and verify that you see your data.